Behaviour
modification – what works, what doesn’t?
Points
to note |
- It is far better to put strategies in place to prevent or minimise
inappropriate behaviour than to react to that behaviour after
it has occurred.
- All behaviour has a purpose or function that produces a result.
For a child with autism, the desired result may be to reduce stress.
- Children with autism need a support plan to address behavioural
issues. Generally, as inappropriate behaviour increases, so too
does punishment. Punishment teaches children that they have done
something wrong. However, it doesn’t teach what is appropriate
or acceptable. This is especially important for children with
autism.
- Children with autism should not be punished for inappropriate
behaviour arising from their disorder, such as being inattentive,
disorganised or misinterpreting verbal instructions.
- Time out may be ineffective for children with autism. In timeout,
the ‘punishment’ is a break from a task that perhaps
the child wanted to avoid in the first place. He is allowed to
sit in the peace and quiet of the corridor which may be a great
relief if the classroom noise causes him stress and anxiety.
- Short term strategies may keep the behaviour under control
but long term strategies are required to avoid an increase in
problems over time.
- When trying to decrease behaviours they will tend to get worse
before they get better. In fact it is a good sign that the method
is working if you notice increases in frequency and intensity
for a short time.
- Remember to stay positive and look for small steps in the increase
or decrease of the behaviour.
|
What you can do
|
- Complete a Behavioural
Profile Checklist, Student
Summary Form and The
ABC of Inappropriate Behaviour. Use these forms to identify
challenging behaviours requiring immediate action and develop
a support plan to manage them. Involve as many people as
possible in the information-gathering process - parents, support
staff etc.
- Only tackle behavioural issues that affect the child’s
ability to learn, if it interferes with other students, or if
it is a safety issue. Obsessive or odd behaviour may keep the
child calm and does not necessarily inhibit learning. For example,
the child may hum softly to himself or flick his fingers in front
of his eyes to keep himself calm. If you tell him to stop he is
likely to become even more anxious and upset as he tries to control
the compulsive behaviour and cope with his stress at the
same time.
- Introduce any changes gradually to minimise disruptive behaviour
and use visual cues wherever possible.
- Most children with autism have an obsession or preferred area
of interest. This interest can help teachers to identify appropriate
rewards or motivators for the child. See Effective rewards and
motivators.
- Maintain a consistent approach to inappropriate behaviour.
Good communication between parents, teachers and support staff
is essential in ensuring a consistent approach. Use a Communication
Book.
- Questions to ask during information-gathering:-
Which behaviours are most difficult or disruptive?
What is happening immediately before the behaviour occurs?
What do you believe is being communicated by the behaviour?
What
skills does the child lack that may contribute to the inappropriate
behaviour?
Describe the consequences that have been tried to stop the behaviour?
Which consequences have failed? Which, if any, have worked?
What motivates the child? Think of his interests and obsessions.
What might be an effective reward system for good behaviour?
What strategies could be implemented to prevent this behaviour?
What consequences will be used when the behaviour occurs
in future?
- Use the The
ABC of Inappropriate Behaviour to develop an action
plan for undesirable behaviour.
- Remember lecturing won't alter the behaviour. Try not to use
threats.
- Identify the consequences of behaviours. A negative consequence
would be punishment, a positive consequence is something the child
looks forward to happening. Positive consequences are far more
powerful to either increase or decrease a behaviour. Sometimes
the consequence you are giving the child may actually be reinforcing
the behaviour, such as the timeout example above. Another example
might be telling the child 'Well done!' in a shrill voice or clapping
loudly. If the child is sensitive to noise this becomes more a
punishmnent than a positive reinforcement.
- Time out. Time out is a consequence where the
child is transferred to a less reinforcing (more boring)
situation for a period of time immediately following an inappropriate
behaviour. As time passes more slowly for children, this
is an effective way to deal with problem behaviours, especially
if the behaviour involves non-compliance, hitting or antagonising
others physically or verbally.
- Time out is often done incorrectly, making it unsuccessful
in changing behaviour. In addition, it takes a period of time
for the child to understand the process of time out and during
this time their behaviours often increase and the amount of time
used in taking them back to time out is considerable.
- Wherever possible, the situation or area the child is sent to
should be devoid of any interesting or distracting objects. It
should never be a dark room or small space, which could scare
the child. It might be an empty hallway or quiet room. It can
be a timeout chair rather than a room.
- What to do. Immediately following a behaviour
say to the child in simple language that he is going to time out
and the reason why. "Time out - no hitting." Remain
calm. Take him to the time out area and do not engage in any other
conservation. Ignore him during the time out.
- There are two methods to determine how long the child stays
in time out - when he is calm or a set time limit. If you are
waiting for the child to calm down and he is crying and likely
to continue crying for some time, you can wait until he takes
a breath and then say, "Good, no crying. Time out finished."
If he continues to cry or be angry say "time out" and
place him back in the room/chair. This can be done until he comes
out of time out in a calm manner. With a timed response you may
decide on 5 minutes and simply let the child out after that period.
- During time out. If the child leaves the
room/chair escort him back as many times as necessary until he
has calmed down or the time limit has been reached. You can leave
a buzzer to tell the child when time out finishes.
- After time out. If you put the child in
time out because he refused to comply with a request, get him
to do the required behaviour after time out and if he does not
comply put him back in time out. Once the behaviour ceases it
is important to act as normally as possible with the child and
not to reprimand him again.
- The child should always have a clear understanding of the kind
of behaviour that will result in timeout. He should be able to
explain, write or draw the reason for being given timeout.
- Always check whether you think the time out could be reinforcing
the behaviour and use it sparingly!
- Use planned ignoring or extinction.
This method can be particularly useful for inappropriate
behaviour that is being reinforced by attention from another person,
however its use is limited. It can only be used when you have
been able to identify what is rewarding to the child and when
you are able to modify this impact. For example, if you ignore
the child but other children give him attention this method may
not work.
- Planned ignoring / extinction involves not attending to the
child's behaviour in any manner including avoiding eye contact,
continuing with your present activity and giving no verbal contact.
- As with any behaviour change the child's behaviour will increase
before it decreases and as such any tantrums will increase. You
have to continue to ignore the child and this can be very trying.
If the child puts himself in danger of being hurt then without
talking remove him from the situation and continue to ignore him.
- Don't give in at the wrong time! This can make the original
problem worse.
- It is essential that this method be paired with a reward system
so that the child can learn the difference between ignoring him
and when you give him attention for a desirable behaviour. However
make sure that NO reinforcement follows the behaviour you are
trying to weaken.
- Redirection and replacement. Replacement
is prompting the child to act appropriately BEFORE he starts to
display an inappropriate behaviour. Therefore you are trying to
prevent undesirable behaviours before they occur. If you see the
child becoming 'wound up' you can intervene first and direct him
into another appropriate activity. This means being in the right
place at the right time, perceiving the child's signals and pre-empting
the situation. Redirection is a method used AFTER you see an inappropriate
behaviour and you then prompt an appropriate one. For example,
instead of throwing sand out of the sandpit, direct the child
to fill a container with the sand.
- Incompatible behaviours. This is similar
to redirection in that you use it AFTER an inappropriate behaviour
is displayed. However instead of moulding the behaviour to a more
appropriate one you introduce an activity that is incompatible
with the problem behaviour. For example, if the child is squealing,
have him blow bubbles until his urge to squeal has stopped. If
he is flapping or biting his hands, give him something to hold
onto such as a stress ball and say 'squeeze.' This is also encouraged
by constructive instructions. Tell the child the behaviour you
want him to perform rather than the behaviour you want
him to stop. Instead of 'no flapping' say 'hands down'.
- Setting up the environment. The environment can
play a large part in the behaviour the child displays. It is also
often easier to change the environment than trying to change a
behaviour that the child is displaying. Therefore it can be useful
to 'set up' the environment to manage behaviours.
- An example of setting up the environment would involve shutting
away equipment that the child likes to break before he
enters the room and bringing it out later when there is an adult
present to supervise or direct the child.
- Giving the child warnings of change, ie. when an activity will
have to finish is also an important part of managing the environment.
Therefore if you require the child to co-operate in carrying out
some action, such as packing up, this can be managed more smoothly
if he is warned in advance.
- Another way you can manage the environment is to alter time
expectations. If 10 minutes is too long for him to sit with a
group, change this expectation to 2 minutes and then slowly work
your way up to the full 10 minutes. Alternatively you can put
him outside the group and slowly bring him into it.
- Offer choices - give the child control. Many inappropriate
behaviours occur due to requests or expectations that are too
difficult for the child to accomplish. Constant commands and directions
can also be frustrating for the child. It is important to give
him choices so that he does not feel that he is constantly being
'bossed' around. Keep the choices limited to two and use visual
cues as some children may only state the last or first thing they
are offered rather than what they really want.
- In summary, an analysis of the negative behaviour needs to be
undertaken, specifically looking at the communicative intent
of the behaviour. When this intent has been identified, teachers
and support staff can work on the skills the child needs to acquire
to prevent this behaviour from re-occurring and put reward systems
in place that will motivate the child to behave in an appropriate
manner.
|
|